This document provides instruction for teaching students to analyze a short story called "A Horse for Matthew". Students will close read and annotate the story to identify what the main character Matthew has in common with a horse named Sundance. They will then answer multiple choice questions about the story and write an open-ended response explaining what Matthew and Sundance have in common, supported by evidence from the story. The document outlines the pre-reading, reading, and post-reading steps and includes the short story passage, multiple choice questions, and a scoring rubric for the assignment.